I got the J.Cat Beauty Roll It Up Auto Lip Liner as part of the brand’s lip vault. 8 items for $26.00! This product retails normally at $2.99 ($299.00/oz). I got the shades Amaranth and Electric Crimson. I gave them a score of 22.
I really liked the eyeliners from this brand so my hopes were high for the lip liners. I was not disappointed.
The product is firm enough that you don’t have to worry too much about continually breaking the tip. The color is true to the container and is vibrant. They don’t seem to bleed and wear about as long as many of the lipsticks.
Ulta has 11 shades and now I have 2 of them. I like this lip liner a lot but I’m not really sure I will buy more. Although, I may replace these when they run out. The shades on offer are a bit odd. A black, brown, dark green shade, and a pink/gray. 2 reds. 1 berry. 1 pink. 1 nude. 1 pink/purple. 1 orange/red. Aside from the black, brown, dark green, pink/gray, and orange/red, I have all the other shades in some other brand. I could very well see replacing some of my NYX lip liners with these when they are gone because they irritate me so much with breaking. That nude in particular might be something for later on.
But for now, I’m pretty happy with my current lip liner stock so these are not on my current wish list.